Books / Feminism / Race

Who Run the [Dystopian] World? [White] Girls

Sharyl Sandberg was right, y’all. In the future, we’re all gonna lean in, and when the world goes to shit, it’s the white ladies that come out on top. A study that shows boys’ numbers lagging behind girls’ in reading might explain the reason for women having to constantly take up the mantle around all these inept future-dudes. But it might better explain the new demographic for the YA (young adult) dystopian novel, which is popularly read by girls and young women. This is neat, considering the sci-fi canon is often thought to belong to male authors and narratives about men, but YA has cornered its niche market by creating tons of female characters for young readers to see themselves reflected in. And even though it’ll take a miracle to get YA to be taken seriously, it’s still a step in the right direction.

But not so fast, have you seen a lot of these books? Like I mentioned above, most of them feature white women, and the majority of those are brunettes. A few characters stray from the tradition, but it seems novelists have found their Tom Cruise of dystopia, their Nathan Drake of YA. Stories with female characters, even stories that aren’t dystopias, rarely stray from this demographic. Just look here:

gathering blue by lois lowry under the never sky by veronica rossi inside out by maria v. snyder whatever became of the squishies by claire chilton viral nation by shaunta grimes divergent by veronica roth matched by ally condie uglies by scott westerfeld shatter me by tahereh mafi delirium by lauren oliver

Brunettes are popular in YA, and often in dystopian novels. Blondes still have all this baggage of being “too pretty” that the reader possibly can’t project onto them. And redheads have that goofy “fiery redhead” stereotype going on like Tamora Pierce’s Song of the Lioness series. Anytime a redhead is passionate or ticked off, people are bound to read into it. But a brunette is a weird neutral balance that doesn’t strike anyone one way or the other, except for maybe the fact that brunettes are generally perceived as smarter.

Even if it’s not the author’s intention to buy into stereotypes, the fact remains that hair color carries too many connotations, and when you need a no-nonsense, get-shit-done, clever, and resourceful leader of future dystopia, with a cool name like Sloane or Tris or Rhine, authors think of a white girl with dark hair. One who’s “pretty but not model pretty.” If you are an author who wants to include themes of female empowerment in your novels, while still wanting your novel to be saleable and have broad appeal, a young white brunette is what you need. Victoria Law of Bitch Magazine notes the lack of diversity on the YA shelf:

To be sure, there seem to be more books with young women of color now compared to a couple of decades ago. But these don’t seem to extend into the dystopian and speculative fiction novels that my daughter brings home. Most still have White girls in the starring roles. Many still have no characters of color; the handful that do seem to cast them as minor (and forgettable) characters. – Do Girls of Color Survive Dystopia?

I’d like to make a note that sometimes authors purposely make their characters racially ambiguous, such as Katniss in the Hunger Games trilogy who is described as having “olive” skin, gray eyes and black hair, or as in Moira Young’s Dust Lands series whose character also has dark hair, and the more “ethnic” name of Saba. However, this matters little. Partly because even when an author makes a distinction of a non-white character, readers are apt to think that character is white, anyway. The other reason is as soon as the movie rights are sold, you can Kat-kiss that racial ambiguity goodbye because the directors are more or less going to cast a non-ambiguously white girl as their heroine, effectively whitewashing her. Blood Red Road has already been sold to Ridley Scott, and I’d be pleasantly surprised if it ended up any other way.

the hunger games by suzanne collins blood red road by moira young

Lastly, be on the lookout for novels that whitewash their covers, This is often a decision of a racist publisher who purposely chooses to misrepresnt a book for sales, even for esteemed writers who are guaranteed to sell, as seen here:

powers poc powers white

dawn poc dawn white

This kind of thing happens again, and again, and again in young adult fiction, of all genres. If you’re looking for a set of diverse dystopian young adult novels, be it for yourself, or for a young person of color who has never seen themselves in a gritty narrative, the blog Diversity in YA has got you covered with these 10 recommendations. YA is actually a tremendously advantageous genre for introducing diverse characters to readers, and while dystopian fiction has gotten on board with engaging female protagonists, it’s still timid and safe to keep picking the same visual archetype. We have been rethinking what a hero looks like. We have to keep rethinking it.

229 thoughts on “Who Run the [Dystopian] World? [White] Girls

  1. I just think women are catching up. Women make up 51% of the earth and have been pushed down for a majority of history.

    In the future when people become wiser, gender & race will lose its importance, in writing, hiring, etc…

  2. Pingback: The Ambiguity of the “Strong Female Character” | Soliloquies

  3. Pingback: Who Run the [Dystopian] World? [White] Girls | maddhineshthoughts

  4. Pingback: My reviews now on GoodReads | Maren Child

  5. Reblogged this on Omg! It's Mcfeisty! and commented:
    I personally would love to read a Dystopian fiction that has both strong male and female characters. I personally really love the “Cinder” and Lunar Chronicle stories but I also feel that the Prince/Emperor in the series is a bit predictable and inept at times. How is it that the future ruler of a country cannot see the facts when they are laid out right in front of him. It is almost as if he was purposefully blind to the world around him.

    Another story featuring a slight nod to Dystopia that I have recently read is Keira Cass’s “Selection” series. This apart from the disastrous “smelling the armpit” cover and the entire premise and execution of the novel is entirely entertaining. Though if you like to read stories with wit, measure, intelligent characters then this book isn’t the right one for you. Most of the time the characters are forced, or it seems that a “rebel” attack is thrown in there just to give the story a plot turn.

  6. Hi!
    Although I do agree with the whole point about the ‘white-skinned’ heroine (I genuinely assumed Katniss to be white, till I read this, and I’m not even white, which says a lot), I’d like to point out that the whole “Blonde Hair and Blue Eyes” is considered pretty is a fact that is true- Think Barbie, who is thought to be the symbol of perfection in everyway.
    Now, when authors who are taking Brunettes as their heroines, I think it’s because they do not want to play into this stereotype, because inevitably, these heroines do end up being pretty (Think Hermione or Katniss) which will again reinforce the whole stereotype, I think.

  7. Yeah, definitely. Speaking as a women of colour myself, I mostly did not realise I was also picturing them white since I took the norm for granted. Honestly, even an empowered (white) woman is still better than no woman in YA.

    I think of the generation that will come after and I sincerely hope that everyone gets represented fairly and authentically or I am going to have to pick out obscure low profile titles in library corners for them – just like I did growing up.

  8. I think you’re thinking of it all wrong. These Dystopia societies are portrayed in the future. Every one is “olive” colored because every race is so intertwined in the melting pot, there is no longer a race. Everyone is the same, equal. Look up what they expect the average human to look like in the future. I’ve seen it and it’s a woman who looks like a mixed child with the blonde kinky hair, olive skin tone, and green eyes. I’m not sure if the authors have ever taken this into consideration, but sooner than later everything we know about race will be gone. After all, there aren’t actually different types of races. These categories that we’ve filled each person into doesn’t mean it’s real. We aren’t White, Black, Asian, or Hispanic, we are just humans.

  9. My spouse and I stumbled over here by a different page and thought I may as well
    check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you.
    Look forward to going over your web page again.

  10. Pingback: The Problem with Dystopians | CULTURE CLASH

  11. Pingback: How We Teach Rebellion: Erasure in YA Dystopia | Writing Radically

  12. Pingback: Why I’m Not Watching The Handmaid’s Tale (Hulu Series) – Geeking Out about It

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s